What’s Quietly Shifting in September? Capacity Steadies as Mix and Rates Rebalance
September presents a complex picture for the freight industry. While some key indicators suggest stability, new regulatory pressures and mixed signals across equipment types indicate a market that is far from settled. Here’s a look at the current dynamics and what is worth monitoring as we head into the final quarter of the year.
Enforcement Headlines, Heightened Capacity Risks
Insurance burdens and pressure on immigrant drivers continue to inject caution into supply growth. The active truck utilization forecast is one point higher than previously expected, but no stronger levels are projected until late 2026. While capacity remains intact for now, regulatory and financial pressures present ongoing risks.
Refrigerated & Flatbed Lead Modest 2025 Growth
Total truck loadings are projected to be up 0.6% for 2025. This positive momentum is driven by strong performance in specific equipment types:
- Refrigerated: Demand remains robust, with a forecast of +0.7% for 2025.
- Flatbed: Reflecting strength in commodity and industrial demand, with a forecast of +2.3% for 2025.
- Dry Van: Loadings projected down -0.6% for the year.
The stronger outlook for food and automotive shipments has provided a small boost across all equipment types. However, a soft job market remains a concern, although the Fed has signaled a potential interest rate cut, which could provide a much-needed stimulus.
Rates Realign at Higher Ground
Rates are showing a rare level of balance, with both spot and contract forecasts now aligned at a 1.6% year-over-year increase.
- Van rates: +1.4%
- Flatbed rates: +1.5%
- Refrigerated rates: +0.6% (despite a stronger August showing)
Projections for 2026 remain steady at a 1.2% increase in total truck rates, pointing to limited growth but also limited downside as the market steadies itself.
Market Signals Show Index Shifts
The Trucking Conditions Index registered a small improvement in July, rising to –1.03 from –1.83 in June. However, the gain came largely from stronger capacity utilization, while freight volume and freight rates both contributed negatively. The index highlights the underlying fragility of the market, where apparent stability is masking weaker fundamentals.
Carrier Population Growth Amid Uncertainty
The carrier population continues to expand, with FMCSA authorizing 5,083 new carriers in July against 4,747 revocations, resulting in a net gain of 316 carriers. This marks the third increase in four months, even as the market continues to operate with 35% more drivers than before the pandemic. While the influx suggests resilience, high insurance costs and regulatory scrutiny could quickly challenge this growth.
What Shippers Should Watch Now
- Driver Capacity Risk: New regulatory policies could quickly change the driver supply landscape, putting pressure on capacity.
- Equipment-Level Divergence: A healthy market for flatbed and refrigerated services does not guarantee the same for dry van services.
- Carrier Population: Growth continues, but high insurance costs and regulatory pressures could tighten capacity faster than anticipated.
A balance of risks and opportunities defines the freight market’s path forward. The headline stability of rates and utilization masks a market under pressure from regulatory changes and uneven demand. For both shippers and carriers, success will depend on staying agile and proactive. Navigating these headwinds requires a clear understanding of the data, the ability to adapt quickly to new challenges, and a strategic outlook that extends beyond the current quarter.